Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
Knoxville Business & Commercial Litigation Attorney > Blog > Construction Law > Change Orders and Legal Consequences in Construction Projects

Change Orders and Legal Consequences in Construction Projects

Construction Projects

Anyone who has managed a construction project in Knoxville knows the plans on day one rarely match the walls that actually go up. Soil conditions shift, owners change their minds about a countertop or a floor plan, and permitting requirements surface mid-build. Each of these moments usually produces the same document: a change order. It sounds like paperwork, but a poorly handled change order can turn a routine project into a costly dispute, which is exactly why Knoxville construction attorneys at our firm find ourselves asked about them so often.

What Actually Counts as a Change Order?

A change order is, at its core, an amendment to the original construction contract. It might add scope, remove scope, adjust the price, or extend the deadline. What makes change orders interesting from a legal standpoint is how differently they can be treated depending on the wording of the underlying contract. Some contracts require every change to be documented in writing and signed by both parties before work begins. Others are looser, allowing verbal instructions from a superintendent to count as authorization. That gap between what the contract requires and what actually happens on site is where a surprising number of disputes originate.

Why Do These Disputes Escalate So Often?

Consider a scenario worth turning over. A contractor performs extra work at an owner’s verbal request, assuming payment will follow because that is how it has always worked on past jobs. The owner later disputes the charge, pointing to a written-change-order clause buried in the contract. Who is right? The answer usually depends on documentation, industry custom, and whether either side can show a course of dealing that modified the written terms. It raises a fair question for anyone signing a construction contract: does the paperwork match how the job actually gets built?

Payment Timing and the Tennessee Prompt Pay Act

Change orders do not just affect scope. They affect when money moves. Under the Prompt Pay Act of 1991, codified at Tenn. Code Ann. § 66-34-101 et seq., Tennessee sets default timelines and penalties for payments on private construction projects, and Tennessee courts have confirmed that withheld retainage can carry meaningful statutory consequences for the party holding the funds. A change order that adds cost without clarifying when that cost becomes payable can create exactly the kind of ambiguity these statutes were designed to address.

What Questions Should a Project Team Be Asking?

Before signing off on any change order, it’s worth pausing on a few questions. Does the change order reference the original contract number and scope so there is no confusion later? Does it specify a new completion date, or only a new price? And has anyone actually confirmed who has authority to approve changes on behalf of the owner? These are not rhetorical questions. Projects have stalled over disagreements about which employee had the authority to say yes.

Change orders are a normal, even healthy, part of construction. Problems tend to arise not from the changes themselves but from assumptions about how they were supposed to be documented. If a change order dispute has stalled a project or a payment, reach out to us. Reynolds, Atkins, Brezina & Stewart, PLLC has represented contractors, subcontractors, and project owners throughout Knoxville, and we are glad to look at your contract and talk through your options.

Source:

tncourts.gov/node/7082237

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn
+